Seeing other employees timesheets - permission issue

One of my colleagues needs to see my timesheets. She is an “HR User” and which has (standard) the Permissions as below

She only can see her own timesheets but not mine (which I would exepect only to be so in case the “Only if Creator” box is checked)

can anyone advise how I have to set this up in order for the above to work?

Try to uncheck " Create User Permission" from the employee

Check under User Permission if there she has a permission restricting her to her own employee ID:

If so, delete the same and ask her to check.