Permissions not working correctly

I have created a new doctype as USER1 and I’ve added it to selling module. I can see it perfectly fine on the selling page.

However when I log in with a second user USER2, who has the exact same profile as I do, I can’t see the item in the selling page.

Keep in mind that the user can navigate via search and use the doctype fine. But the view is not showing correctly on the selling page.
What’s going on here?

This is the second user profile

This is the doctype permissions settings when creating it.